Is economics a science?

Is economics a science?
Andri W. Stahel
Real-world economics review
Poziom: zaawansowane
Perspektywy: Ekonomia złożoności, Ekonomia neoklasyczna
Temat: philosophy of economics
Formularz: Journal Article & Book Chapter
Link: http://www.paecon.net/PAEReview/issue94/Stahel94.pdf
Photo by Vlad Tchompalov on Unsplash

Abstract:

"After more than a century of near-complete hegemony of the neoclassic paradigm in the subject, we take it for granted that economics, as it is nowadays practiced, is a science in the same sense as other fields of scientific inquiry. Although many critiques and dissenting voices can and have been heard questioning various aspects of different theories and models, the overall scientificity of economics as such has mostly been left unquestioned. Economists still present themselves as experts, Nobel and various other prizes in economics are awarded, thousands of papers are published in “scientific journals”, and hundreds of thousands of students engage in their studies worldwide to become professional economists, all following a remarkably similar student plan and curriculum all around the world. However, in this paper, I go a step further and ask the question, not without hesitation due to the seriousness of the negative answer I propose to it, whether economics as it is practiced nowadays and presented to the public at large, can be considered a science at all. More than the question about whether we have good or bad economic science, it is the whole edifice and the way modern economics has come to be thus being questioned." Andri W. Stahel

Comment from our editors:

The author questions the status of modern economics. Can economics predict people's behavior with the use of mathematic models? Does economics belong with human sciences or natural sciences?
Through Lakatos and Popper and the history of economic thought, the analogy between economics and physics is questioned. It is this analogy enabling mainstream economists to explain that economic analysis through models and assumed 'natural laws' is the apt approach to the subject, by contrast to path-dependent approaches such as the german historical school, for example. For them, economics is an objective, neutral science rather than a complex, dynamic web of human interactions unfit for rational modelling.

Go to: Is economics a science?

This material has been suggested and edited by:

Constance André--Aigret
Tags: history of economic thought | mathematisation of economics | methodology | Science | Working Paper
In this lecture, Beatrice Cherrier explains why it is worth to research the history of JEL codes. The changing relationship between theory and application and the rise and death of new economic topics in the XXth century through the successive revisions of the classification system economists use to publish, recruit and navigate their discipline. 2017 Level: początkujący Understanding the transformation of Economics through the history of JEL codes Beatrice Cherrier Lecture series at the Ruhr-University Bochum Jason Collins explains how his “evolutionary approach” to decision-making relates to other approaches of behaviour. This piece therefore not only serves as a good introduction to this “evolutionary approach” but also serves as a great introduction to these other approaches of behaviour namely neoclassical perfect rationality which involves mainly probability … 2015 Level: początkujący Please, not another bias! An evolutionary take on behavioural economics. Jason Collins www.jasoncollins.blog La crisis del modelo de desarrollo ha dado una nueva vigencia a organizaciones que no pertenecen ni al sector privado tradicional ni al sector público. Estas organizaciones reciben diferentes apelaciones, tercer sector, economía solidaria, economía social, economía popular, organizaciones de desarrollo social, etc. Este trabajo se propone analizar los contextos de utilización de algunos de estos términos que designan las actividades que escapan a la lógica capitalista y a la lógica de la administración pública. La nueva constitución venezolana de 2000 incluye en su artículo 184 un término nuevo en el país, el de economía social. Se trata de un término que data del siglo XIX, cuando era utilizado sobre todo en el mundo francófono. La crisis del modelo de desarrollo fordista ha llevado a su reactualización a partir de los años 1980. Las definiciones que tiene varían según los países. Este trabajo tiene como propósito precisar el significado de este término, y de otros que le son afines. Luego, se definen algunos criterios para la delimitación de un sector de economía social en Venezuela. 2001 Level: zaawansowane Economía social y economía solidaria: Intento de definición Oscar Bastidas Delgado, Madeleine Richer Sistema de Información Científica Redalyc: Red de Revistas Científicas This course introduces students to the relevance of gender relations in economics as a discipline and in economic processes and outcomes. The course covers three main components of gender in economics and the economy: (1) the gendered nature of the construction and reproduction of economic theory and thought; (2) the relevance and role of gender in economic decision-making; and (3) differences in economic outcomes based on gender. We wil touch on the relevance of gender and gender relations in at least each of the following topics: economic theory; the history of economic thought; human capital accumulation; labor market discrimination; macroeconomic policy, including gender budgeting; household economics; basic econometrics; and economic crises. 2019 Level: początkujący Gender Relations and Economics Alyssa Schneebaum Vienna University of Economics and Business Der Text klärt zunächst den Begriff der Metaphysik, der sich auch bei Adam Smith finden lässt. Es zeigt sich, dass die Metaphysik ein formales Schema ist, in dem wissenschaftliche Aussagen formuliert werden, ohne dieses Schema selbst zu reflektieren. Die Wirtschaftswissenschaften erscheinen in Forschung und Anwendung als formal exakte Theorie, die der physikalischen Mechanik bis in die mathematischen Details gleicht. Die Mechanik fungiert hier als verborgene Metaphysik. 2014 Level: zaawansowane Verborgene metaphysische Voraussetzungen in der zeitgenössischen Wirtschaftslehre Karl-Heinz Brodbeck Institut für Ökonomie und Philosophie Cusanus Hochschule Discusión sobre la relación negativa entre desigualdad y el movilidad social. Los últimos estudios realizados en los países de OECD y en los Estados Unidos aportan importantes elementos para analizar el deterioro de la movilidad social. 2019 Level: początkujący Nuevos estudios sobre desigualdad Sergio Reuben-Soto Blog Escudrojo website The total sum of squares and the total degrees of freedoms are disaggregated by calculating in sample variance and "between" sample variance and their respective degrees of freedoms. It is demonstrated numerically that both these measures add up to the total sum of squares and the total degrees of freedom. 2012 Level: początkujący ANOVA 2: Calculating SSW and SSB (total sum of squares within and between)   Khan Academy

Wesprzyj

Ten projekt został stworzony przez Sieć na rzecz Pluralistycznej Ekonomii (Netzwerk Plurale Ökonomik e.V.).  Jest on zaangażowany w różnorodność i niezależność i jest zależny od darowizn od ludzi takich jak Ty. Regularne lub jednorazowe datki będą bardzo mile widziane.

 

Wesprzyj