Development of heterodox economics at public German universities since the 1970s

Development of heterodox economics at public German universities since the 1970s
Sebastian Thieme, Arne Heise
Zentrum für Ökonomische und Soziologische Studien, Universität Hamburg, 2016
Grado: debutante
Perspectivas: Escuela Austriaca, Economía conductual, Economía de la complejidad, Economía ecológica, Economía evolutiva, Economía feminista, Economia institucionalista, Economía política Marxista, Otros, Economía poskeynesiana
Topic: Reflexión sobre economía
Format: Working Paper
Enlace: http://hdl.handle.net/10419/146949

Photo by Nathan Dumlao on Unsplash

Exploring Economics Working Paper Selection

We collect and republish selected Working Papers and Journal Articles on Exploring Economics.

Learn more

Development of heterodox economics at public German universities since the 1970s

Sebastian Thieme, Arne Heise | 2016

 

Abstract: This article discusses the development of 'heterodox' economics at universities in Germany since the 1970s. Based on Lakatos' concept of scientific research programmes (SRP), the article introduces a classification of economics in order to clarify the understanding of variety within economics, especially in the case of Germany. Based on this classification and taking into account the different kinds of capital (economic, social and symbolic) available to heterodox economists, this article aims to show how heterodox economics in Germany has developed from the early 1970s until the present day. It will be shown that the heterodox schools expanded in the 1970s, but marginalisation took hold again by the 1980s and ultimately left German heterodox economics in a state of near-extinction today. From this, it follows that the history of heterodoxy in Germany is an unequal 'battle of the paradigms', and can only be told as the story of a failure.

Key words: heterodox economics, pluralisation, philosophy of science, sociology of science, Germany

Read here

 

Stay tuned!

Subscribe to our newsletter to learn about new debates, conferences and writing workshops.

Subscribe!

Go to: Development of heterodox economics at public German universities since the 1970s

This material has been suggested and edited by:

Samuel Decker
Tags: heterodoxy | history of economic thought | history of economics | mainstream critique | pluralist economics | sociology | Sociology of Science | Working Paper
This Forum in the Boston Review deals with the role of economics in modern policymaking and presents a wide set of perspectives on the topic. The opening text by Suresh Naidu, Dani Rodrik and Gabriel Zucman aims to answer a range of common criticisms against the modern, neoclassical science of economics and its influence on public discussions.
2019
Level: debutante
Economics After Neoliberalism
Suresh Naidu, Dani Rodrik, Gabriel Zucman
Boston Review
Ihre Erklärungs- und Deutungslogik hat die Ökonomik in der zweiten Hälfte des 20. Jahrhunderts selbstbewusst auf nahezu alle gesellschaftlichen Phänomene ausgedehnt. Auch auf Diskriminierung und Rassismus. Leider dreht sich auch bei diesem Thema die Mainstream-Ökonomik um sich selbst, argumentieren Steffen Haag und Elena Goschin.
Level: debutante
Ökonomie der Diskriminierung
Steffen Haag und Elena Goschin
Netzwerk Plurale Ökonomik
Im Zuge der Herausbildung der Finanzmärkte und unter dem Eindruck der Finanzkrise ist unter dem Label „Performativität der Ökonomik“ ein weiterer Diskussionsstrang entstanden:
2018
Level: adelantado
Performativität in der Marktökonomie. Worum sorgen sich Ökonom*innen?
PD Dr. Katrin Hirte
Plurale Ökonomik Jena
Die Studie basiert auf einer Online-Umfrage unter 448 Promovierenden im Fach Volkswirtschaftslehre (VWL) an Universitäten und Graduiertenschulen im deutschsprachigen Raum.
Level: debutante
Neues ökonomisches Denken in der Doktorandenausbildung
Tom Bauermann, Michael Roos, Johanna Meier
Forschungsinstitut für gesellschaftliche Weiterentwicklung (FGW)
In diesem Vortrag in ökonomischer Philosophie stellt Dr.in Silja Graupe, Lehrende und Mitbegründerin der Cusanus Hochschule für Gesellschaftsgestaltung eine neue Form der Erkenntnisgewinnung im Bereich ökonomischer Entscheidungen vor. Als Gegenströmung zur Verhaltensökonomik oder zu rationaler Nutzenmaximierung werden Gemeinsinn, Imagination und Pluralität in der Ökonomie verankert.
2020
Level: perito
Wie wir Ökonomie in Krisenzeiten neu gestalten können.
Dr. Silja Graupe
Cusanus Hochschule für Gesellschaftsbildung
This paper investigates how the concept of public purpose is used in Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). As a common denominator among political scientists, the idea of public purpose is that economic actions should aim at benefiting the majority of the society. However, the concept is to be considered as an ideal of a vague nature, which is highly dependent on societal context and, hence, subject to change over time. MMT stresses that government spending plans should be designed to pursue a certain socio-economic mandate and not to meet any particular financial outcome. The concept of public purpose is heavily used in this theoretical body of thought and often referred to in the context of policy proposals as the ideas of universal job guarantee and banking reform proposals show. MMT scholars use the concept as a pragmatic benchmark against which policies can be assessed. With regards to the definition of public propose, MMT scholars agree that it is dependent on the social-cultural context. Nevertheless, MMT scholars view universal access to material means of survival as universally applicable and in that sense as the lowest possible common denominator.
2020
Level: adelantado
Modern Monetary Theory and the public purpose
Dirk H. Ehnts, Maurice Höfgen
Institute for International Political Economy Berlin

Donar

Este proyecto es presentado por la Network for Pluralist Economics (Netzwerk Plurale Ökonomik e.V.) y socios internacionales.  Está comprometida con la diversidad y la independencia y depende de las donaciones de personas como tú. Donaciones regulares o puntuales serán muy apreciadas!

 

Donar