"Postcolonialism meets Economics" A Discussion with Prof. Eiman Zein-Elabdin

"Postcolonialism meets Economics" A Discussion with Prof. Eiman Zein-Elabdin
Prof. Eiman Zein-Elabdin and Danish Khan
Inequality, Poverty, Power & Social Justice Initiative, 2021
Level: mittel
Perspektive: Diverse
Thema: Kapitalismuskritik, Nord-Süd-Beziehungen & Entwicklung, Reflexion der Ökonomik
Format: Interview
Dauer: 01:01:32
Link: https://fb.watch/aFJZ4sQ9ZB/

The postcolonial critique of Economics is one of the sharpest and most comprehensive indictments of the discipline, highlighting the discipline's limited treatment of power and culture and the incompatibility of the discipline's theoretical frameworks and predictions with the contexts of most formerly colonised territories. This interview of Prof. Eiman Zein-Elabdin provides important insights into this rich literature. Within the interview, Prof. Eiman Zein-Elabdin discusses what got her interested in postcolonial approaches to economics, the overlaps between this framework and institutional economics, how the mode of analysis handles duality and the less discussed differences between centrally planned and centrally managed economies specifically how the latter is more suited to understanding the experience of developing countries. Finally, she also discusses the contemporary applications of postcolonial approaches to economics by engaging with how it can be used to understand the growing wealth and income inequality as well as how it can be a useful tool for understanding the political economy of militarisation beyond the mainstream conceptualisations.

Comment from our editors:

This is a brilliant interview, made even better by the amazing questions from Danish Khan. Apart from breaking down a seemingly abstract concept into a relatable framework, this interview starts with a detailed discussion of the interdisciplinary bodies of work that shaped the work of Eiman Zein-Elabdin from the writings of Vandana Shiva to Arturo Escobar. This is a good sneak peek into the journey and the thought process behind this seminal body of work, the details of which are rarely found in most academic discussions. The understanding of colonisation used in this discussion is also a departure from most academic literature as she also considers pre-european domination such as the muslimisation of Africa and other forms of domination before that and how they shaped the economic systems of their colonies, complicating the mainstream understanding of the interactions of colonisation and economics or economic processes. Everyone who is interested in the interactions of power, culture and economics should definitely watch this!

Go to: "Postcolonialism meets Economics" A Discussion with Prof. Eiman Zein-Elabdin

This material has been suggested and edited by:

Nedson Ng'oma
Tags: Decolonise Economics | development | institutional economics | mainstream critique | post-development | Postcolonial Approaches
In this podcast, Nalia Kabeer talks about her work, criticising the way in which Randomized Control Trials (RCTs) is adopted as a sole form of impact assessment. At the beginning of the talk, she briefly describes The Ultra Poor Project (the context of her study), RCTs and its critiques (such as lack of acknowledgement of human agency, heterogeneity, and social context); also, the problem that most RCTs practitioners do not allow for qualitative research conducted in an integrated way as it might cause their studies “being contaminated.”
2019
Level: leicht
Naila Kabeer on Why Randomized Controlled Trials need to include Human Agency
Naila Kabeer (Interviewed by Duncan Green)
Poverty to Power
An vielen Stellen scheinen die Dinge nicht so zu laufen, wie sie laufen sollten: die ökonomische Ungleichheit ist groß, bloßes Wohnen wird immer teurer, öffentliche Güter wie Krankenhäuser oder Universitäten geraten unter einen ökonomischen Erfolgsdruck, der ihrer ursprünglichen Funktion nicht gut tut. Der renommierte Philosoph Axel Honneth erkennt ein allgemeines …
2016
Level: leicht
Sozialismus oder Liberalismus?
SRF Kultur
Sternstunde Philosophie, SRF Kultur
Die Volkswirtschaftslehre begnügt sich damit, eine Lehre der Mechanik des aktuellen Wirtschaftssystems zu sein, eine Art Kapitalistik. Es war fahrlässig, bei dieser geschichts- und zukunftslosen Wirtschaftswissenschaft stehenzubleiben. Eine Reise in die Vergangenheit der Disziplin zeigt, dass eine bessere Ökonomik denkbar ist, argumentiert Frank Fehlberg.
Level: leicht
Objektfixierung – Wie die VWL ihre Dynamik verlor
Frank Fehlberg
Netzwerk Plurale Ökonomik
In diesem Interview geht es insbesondere um die Beschäftigung mit der Ungleichheit, der sich Thomas Piketty in seinen Büchern "Das Kapital im 21. Jahrhundert" sowie "Kapital und Ideologie" widmet.
2020
Level: leicht
Thomas Piketty im Gespräch über Ungleichheit und Kapitalismus
SRF Kultur
Sternstunde Philosophie, SRF Kultur
In parallel to rising inflation numbers, the concept of profit inflation has clearly risen to prominence in recent years. But what is it exactly? This dossier aims not only to collect the most important publications on profit inflation but also intends to map out the development of the discourse and the different positions within the debate.
2024
Level: mittel
Profit Inflation: Mapping the debate
Theresa Walter
Exploring Economics
Most mainstream neoclassical economists completely failed to anticipate the crisis which broke in 2007 and 2008. There is however a long tradition of economic analysis which emphasises how growth in a capitalist economy leads to an accumulation of tensions and results in periodic crises. This paper first reviews the work of Karl Marx who was one of the first writers to incorporate an analysis of periodic crisis in his analysis of capitalist accumulation. The paper then considers the approach of various subsequent Marxian writers, most of whom locate periodic cyclical crises within the framework of longer-term phases of capitalist development, the most recent of which is generally seen as having begun in the 1980s. The paper also looks at the analyses of Thorstein Veblen and Wesley Claire Mitchell, two US institutionalist economists who stressed the role of finance and its contribution to generating periodic crises, and the Italian Circuitist writers who stress the problematic challenge of ensuring that bank advances to productive enterprises can successfully be repaid.
2014
Level: mittel
Finance and Crisis: Marxian, Institutionalist and Circuitist approaches
Georgios Argitis, Trevor Evans, Jo Michell, Jan Toporowski
Institute for International Political Economy Berlin

Spenden

Um sich weiterhin für Pluralismus und Vielfalt in der Ökonomik einzusetzen, benötigt das Netzwerk Plurale Ökonomik e.V. Unterstützung von Leuten wie dir. Deshalb freuen wir uns sehr über eine einmalige oder dauerhafte Spende.

Spenden